Changing Tables: What Works (and What Doesn’t) from a Mom of 5
Not all changing tables are created equal! After five babies, I’ve learned what truly works (and what’s a waste of space). In this guide, I’m sharing the best-changing table options, whether you prefer a dresser, Pack & Play, or traditional setup, so you can find the perfect fit for your home and lifestyle.
Baby number five is on the way, and while you’d think I’d have all the details figured out by now, there are still things that take some planning, like where to set up a changing table.
With each baby, I’ve tried different setups. At one point, I had a dedicated changing station in the playroom, but in our new home, we don’t have a separate playroom, so I knew I needed to get creative.
The nursery? Well, that’s still doubling as a guest room for now.
We have family coming to help with the older kids while I’m in the hospital and recovering from my c-section, so it just made sense to keep that space available for them.
And since the baby will be in our bedroom for the first few months anyway, setting up a changing station there felt like the most practical choice.
Now, I’ll be the first to say that a changing table isn’t necessarily a must-have, but let me tell you, it makes life a lot easier.
Especially in those newborn days when diaper changes feel endless. And with a c-section recovery ahead of me, bending down to change diapers on the floor just isn’t an option. I needed a setup that was convenient, functional, and easy on my healing body.
That’s what led me to revisit all the different changing table options, what actually works, what’s not worth the space, and which setup makes the most sense for different lifestyles.
Whether you’re setting up a nursery, making room in your bedroom, or just figuring out what will make those diaper changes easier, I’m breaking it all down here.
Choosing a Changing Table
With a new baby on the way, choosing the right changing table is one of those decisions that can make daily life so much easier, or more frustrating.
After four babies and with number five on the way, I’ve tested just about every setup out there, from traditional changing tables to dressers and even Pack & Plays.
Some were total game changers, while others just took up space.
In this guide, I’m breaking down what actually works, what doesn’t, and how to choose the best-changing table for your home, lifestyle, and budget.
Pack-and-Play Changing Table
With my first baby, I was lucky enough to win a Pack-and-Play with a built-in changing table at a baby event at our local mall.
At the time, I didn’t realize just how practical it would be, but it quickly became one of the most useful baby items we owned.
Not only did it serve as a convenient diaper-changing station in those early newborn days, but it also doubled as a safe sleep space, a travel crib, and even a play yard as my baby grew.
Fast forward eight years (and several babies later), I may have misplaced the bassinet attachment and changing table piece along the way, but we still use that same Pack-and-Play today!
It’s perfect for visiting family who need a spot for their little ones to sleep, and we still bring it along when we travel. That kind of longevity makes it a great investment.
Pack-And-Play Pro’s
Multi-Use Functionality: It’s not just a changing table; it’s also a bassinet, crib, and play space, making it a smart buy if you love versatility.
Great for Small Spaces: If you don’t have room for a separate changing table or nursery furniture, this can serve multiple purposes without taking up extra space.
Ideal for Travel or Grandparents’ Homes: The portability makes it a fantastic option for travel or as an extra sleeping and changing area at a grandparent’s house.
Budget-Friendly: Instead of buying a separate crib, changing table, and playpen, you get all three in one.
Pack-And-Play Con’s
Changing Table Weight Limit: Many Pack-and-Play changing tables have weight limits (often around 15-25 lbs), meaning your baby may outgrow it quickly.
Storage Limitations: Some models have built-in storage, but others don’t so you may need a nearby caddy for diapers and wipes.
Setup and Breakdown: While easy to use once assembled, setting up and taking down the attachments (especially the changing table piece) can sometimes be a hassle. I cannot tell you how many times my husband and I have been frustrated trying to break down a pack-and-play.
Final Thoughts on Pack-And-Plays
Overall, if you’re looking for a space-saving, travel-friendly option that grows with your baby, a Pack-and-Play with a changing table can be a fantastic choice! Just keep in mind the weight limits and storage needs when deciding if it’s the right fit for your lifestyle.
Standard Changing Table
With my second, third, and fourth babies, I opted for a traditional changing table, and it worked well for our needs.
Unlike multi-use options like a Pack-and-Play or a dresser, a standard changing table is designed solely for diaper changes, no extra frills, just a dedicated space to get the job done.
One of the biggest perks? Affordability. Standard changing tables tend to be cheaper than both Pack-and-Plays and dresser setups, making them a great budget-friendly choice.
Many designs come with built-in shelves, which help keep diapers, wipes, and creams organized and within arm’s reach.
I loved keeping baskets on my shelves to keep these items organized, along with a few outfits for when the baby has an unexpected blowout or accident while changing them.
This makes diaper changes quick and convenient, especially in those sleep-deprived newborn days.
These changing tables are also lightweight and easy to move, so if you like the idea of having a dedicated changing station but don’t want to commit to a bulky piece of furniture, they’re a great in-between option. I kept our in our playroom in the old house, and it was nice I could easily move it if I ever decided to change up the playroom furniture.
However, they’re also single-purpose, unlike a dresser that can grow with your child, a standard changing table typically won’t have much use beyond the diaper years.
Standard Changing Table Pros
Budget-Friendly: One of the most affordable changing table options available.
Lightweight and Portable: These can be moved easily if needed.
Organized Storage: Many designs have built-in shelves or cubbies to keep diapering essentials within reach.
Perfect for Dedicated Changing Spaces: If you have the space for a separate nursery setup, this keeps everything neat and convenient.
Standard Changing Table Cons
Single-Purpose: Once your baby is out of diapers, it doesn’t have much use.
Takes Up Space & Short Lifespan: Unlike a dresser, which has long-term functionality, a standard changing table is another piece of furniture that will eventually be outgrown.
Limited Weight Capacity: Most are designed for use in the early months and may not be suitable as your baby gets bigger.
Final Thoughts on Standard Changing Tables
If you’re looking for a simple, budget-friendly solution that keeps diapering supplies neatly organized and easily accessible, a traditional changing table is a great option, just keep in mind that it won’t grow with your child like a dresser would.
Dresser with Built-in Changing Table
I’ve never personally owned a dresser with a built-in changing table, but I’ve always been intrigued by them.
These are designed as a mix between a traditional dresser and a changing station, making them a stylish yet practical piece of furniture for a nursery.
Some models come with a removable changing topper, allowing the dresser to transition into a regular piece of furniture as your baby grows, while others have a permanently attached changing area.
While I loved the idea of a multi-use piece, I was always a little hesitant about the longevity, and sometimes we honestly just didn’t have the space for a full-sized dresser.
Would it truly grow with my child, or would the changing table piece make it feel outdated once we were out of the diaper phase? If you’re considering this option, it’s worth looking into models with a removable topper for the best long-term use.
Dresser with Built-in Changing Table Pros
Multi-Use & Space-Saving: Functions as both a dresser and a changing table, eliminating the need for extra furniture.
Stylish Nursery Look: Fits seamlessly into nursery décor and transitions well into a toddler or big kid room.
Long-Term Investment: If you choose one with a removable topper, it can last for years beyond the baby stage.
Great for Storage: Built-in drawers provide plenty of space for diapers, clothes, and baby essentials.
Dresser with Built-in Changing Table Cons
Price: Typically more expensive than a standard changing table or dresser alone.
Limited Longevity: If the topper isn’t removable, the dresser may feel outdated once your baby is out of diapers.
Heavy & Less Portable: Unlike a Pack-and-Play or standalone changing table, this isn’t easy to move around.
Final Thoughts on Dresser with Built-in Changing Tables
If you love the idea of a functional, long-lasting piece of furniture, a dresser with a built-in changing table, and have the space, it might be worth the investment. Just be sure to check if the topper is removable to maximize its longevity!
Crib with Built-in Changing Table
I’ve never personally used a crib with a built-in changing table, but I’ve always been curious about them. These cribs are designed with an attached changing station, making them a great space-saving option for smaller nurseries. They seem like a practical all-in-one solution, especially for parents who want everything in one compact setup.
However, my biggest hesitation with these cribs was longevity. While the idea of having a changing table right next to the crib is convenient for the newborn stage, I worried about how useful it would be long-term.
Once your baby transitions out of the crib, the attached changing table might feel outdated or unnecessary, depending on the design, or vice versa, when your little one is out of diapers, the changing table attachment can’t be removed.
Some models convert into toddler beds and even full-sized beds, but the changing table doesn’t always serve much purpose after the diaper stage.
That said, if you’re working with a small space and want an all-in-one nursery piece, this could be a great solution, just keep in mind the transition plan for when your little one outgrows the crib.
Crib with Built-in Changing Table Pros
Great for Small Nurseries: Perfect if you’re trying to maximize space without extra furniture.
All-in-One Convenience: Everything is within arm’s reach for quick diaper changes.
Long-Term Use (Depending on Model): Some cribs convert into toddler or full-size beds, making it a multi-stage investment.
Budget-Friendly in the Short Term: Often cheaper than buying a separate crib and changing table.
Crib with Built-in Changing Table Cons
Longevity Concerns: The changing table may become useless once your child transitions out of the crib.
Less Flexible Room Layout: Since the changing table is attached, you can’t rearrange the furniture as easily.
Storage Limitations: Some models offer extra drawers, but others have minimal storage space.
Final Thoughts on Crib with Built-in Changing Tables
If you need to save space and want a streamlined nursery setup, a crib with a built-in changing table could be a solid choice. Just be sure to consider how it will work for your family once the crib days are over!
Dresser with Changing Pad on Top
This time around, I’m using a dresser with a changing pad on top, and honestly, I love how practical and space-saving it is.
Unlike a traditional changing table, a dresser can grow with your child, making it a great long-term investment. Whether you go for a full-sized dresser or a smaller one, this option gives you both storage and functionality without sacrificing space.
Since our nursery is currently doubling as a guest room, the changing table will be in my bedroom, especially since the baby will be sleeping in a bassinet in our room for the first few months.
I needed something compact yet efficient, so I chose a three-drawer dresser that fits perfectly in our space. The top serves as a changing station now, but once the diaper days are over, I can simply remove the pad and still have a functional piece of furniture for years to come.
One of the biggest benefits? Built-in storage! Unlike standalone changing tables, which often have open shelves, a dresser keeps everything neatly tucked away, making the space feel less cluttered.
Plus, I love that I can repurpose the drawers over time—first for diapers and onesies, later for toddler clothes and big-kid essentials.
If you go this route, just make sure to secure the changing pad with either a non-slip mat or straps to keep it safely in place.
Dresser with Changing Pad on Top Pros
Long-Term Use: Unlike a traditional changing table, a dresser remains useful well beyond the baby stage.
Customizable to Your Space: Choose a full-sized dresser for maximum storage or a smaller one to fit a compact nursery.
Clutter-Free Storage: Keeps baby essentials organized and out of sight.
Budget-Friendly Over Time: While it may cost more upfront than a standard changing table, you won’t need to replace it later.
Dresser with Changing Pad on Top Cons
Requires a Secure Setup: You’ll need a non-slip pad or straps to keep the changing pad stable.
Higher Upfront Cost: A quality dresser can be more expensive than a basic changing table.
Not as Portable: Unlike a Pack-and-Play or standalone changing table, a dresser stays put once it’s in place.
Final Thoughts on Crib with Built-in Changing Tables
For me, this setup just makes sense, it’s space-efficient, functional, and will still be useful long after we’ve said goodbye to diapers. If you’re looking for a practical, long-term nursery solution, a dresser with a changing pad on top is definitely worth considering!
No Right or Wrong, Just the Best Fit for Your Family
At the end of the day, there’s no one-size-fits-all changing table setup, it’s all about what works best for your family, home, and lifestyle.
After five babies, I’ve learned that what feels like the perfect setup with one baby might not work at all for the next.
Space, budget, convenience, and even recovery considerations (like my upcoming c-section) all play a role in what makes the most sense.
For this baby, a small dresser with a changing pad on top in my bedroom felt like the best fit. But for you, it might be a Pack-and-Play with a changing attachment, a traditional changing table, or a simple diaper caddy with a changing pad.
No matter what setup you choose, the most important thing is making those countless diaper changes as easy and comfortable as possible because, trust me, there will be a lot of them!
And speaking of getting prepared, if you’re planning your changing table, you’re probably also getting ready for the hospital, too!
If you haven’t already, check out my Hospital Bag Checklist to make sure you have everything you need for those first few days with baby. Just like with changing tables, what you pack should be about comfort and practicality, because those little details make a big difference when you’re navigating the newborn stage.
For more on motherhood, cozy recipes, homemaking tips, and seasonal inspiration, be sure to follow me on Instagram, Facebook, Pinterest, and YouTube.
What kind of changing table setup are you going with? Let me know in the comments—I love hearing what works for other moms!
Cheering you on as you prep for baby, one diaper change at a time! 🎉 Xoxo- Tandra
